Funny name, serious implications: The basics of spendthrift clauses

Financial advisors and tax professionals seeking to help clients protect trust assets in the event of divorce, lawsuits or an extravagant heir should know the basics of a spendthrift clause.

An ever-growing alphabet soup of trust entities enable planners to assist clients in moving assets out of their taxable estates. However, without the right so-called "spendthrift" protections in place and an understanding that the rules for those clauses vary a great deal between states, the clients could face threats to the orderly distribution of their estates. Such problems might be avoided by planners suggesting that clients speak with an attorney who is knowledgeable on the many rules governing trusts and beneficiaries, three lawyers told Financial Planning.

READ MORE: Meet the CDFA, a certification for advisors with wealthy clients facing divorce

The idea for spendthrift clauses — or separate standalone entities known as spendthrift trusts — stems from the principle behind putting a professional trustee between the asset owner and any beneficiaries who "foolishly spend their inheritance on unproductive things," according to Griffin Bridgers, a member with the Hutchins & Associates law firm. In recent decades, the popularity of shielding assets from divorce or lawsuits prior to distribution to the trust's beneficiaries has also run into state-level variance around possible exceptions that void spendthrift clauses for the purposes of child support, alimony or a few other reasons.

"In the current environment, financial advisors are often pushed into more of a review and summary function for trusts, and perhaps the lowest-hanging fruit is simply confirming that a spendthrift clause exists and explaining its benefits to clients," Bridgers said. 

The clause "protects the trust assets from divorce," but that plays out differently depending on whether the location of the entity was established under "a more protective state law," according to Steven Oshins, an attorney with law firm Oshins & Associates. His firm maintains rankings of the states tracking, for example, their treatment of the so-called exception creditors that may access assets protected by spendthrift clauses and their rules for "fraudulent" or "voidable" transfers. Besides divorces, the spendthrift clauses or trusts loom as important safeguards in litigation against clients such as physicians who may face frequent lawsuits, Oshins said.

"Financial advisors should make sure to work with estate planning attorneys who include asset protection in their planning. That way, when they have a client who should take some chips off the table, they have the means to put the planning in place," Oshins said. "One of the key items that is missed all the time is that different states have different levels of spendthrift protection. It is surprising that nearly all estate planning attorneys limit their trust situs to their home jurisdiction, rather than thinking outside the box and using the better laws found in other jurisdictions."

READ MORE: 3 types of trusts that could help wealthy clients' estate plans

As they guide clients through the concept, the advisors who don't have law licenses will need to "be careful how deep and how far they go" into the actual content of the spendthrift clauses, according to Martin Shenkman, the founder of Shenkman Law. Trust and estate attorneys must manage the drafting and language of the clause, or there could be implications to advisors themselves and their errors and omissions (E&O) insurance policies, he said.

"Financial advisors should be proactively involved in most phases of estate planning, and they should be the catalysts for estate planning," Shenkman said. "If you as a financial advisor cross the line into the unauthorized practice of law, you may not have coverage under your E&O policy."

The issues connected to spendthrift clauses carry a major impact to multigenerational clients passing down their wealth. They won't have time for a redo if they make a mistake.

"The spendthrift clause is only effective so long as property is in the trust," Bridgers said. "Once the toothpaste is out of the tube, you can't put it back in and regain the protection."

READ MORE: How a life insurance strategy could save some wealthy estates millions

Even as they stop short of what may be considered legal services or advice, the advisors can still disavow their clients of "this strange misconception that, 'Oh, I set it up. I don't have to look at it because it's done,'" Shenkman said. 

For example, they ought to keep in mind that "almost every older trust" includes language transferring assets to an heir at a specified age, but that scenario isn't taking into account what could happen if, say, the beneficiary gets divorced or sued a year later, he said. The advisors can make a big difference by spotting the potential problem and sending them to an estate attorney.

"That is in an incredibly common situation," Shenkman said. "That's a huge asset protection play. That to me is the kind of place where wealth advisors have a very valuable role."

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Practice and client management Tax Regulation and compliance Estate planning Trusts
MORE FROM FINANCIAL PLANNING