$500M team chooses Commonwealth after sale of longtime IBD

Fresh off a record year in 2018 with $64.3 million in gross recruited revenue, Commonwealth Financial Network added a team with more than $500 million in client account assets.

Financial advisors Neil Hoyt, Rachel Roney, Jeffrey Klein, Sonnet Loftus and Paul Ahrens of Michael Roberts Associates left Cadaret, Grant after nearly three decades to align with Commonwealth, the firms said this week. The team and their former broker-dealer both have headquarters in Syracuse, New York.

Commonwealth Financial Network's annual revenue

Commonwealth produced $1.2 billion in revenue in 2017, making it the No. 4 IBD on Financial Planning’s FP50 list of the largest firms in the space. At the firm’s annual conference, executives said they expected to reach $1.4 billion in 2018 — or about $700,000 per advisor — in addition to the recruiting record.

The average production of incoming advisors in 2018 topped $500,000 per producer, according to Andrew Daniels, Commonwealth’s managing principal for business development. The record resulted from attracting “a relatively small number of relatively high producers” to the firm, he says.

Hoyt’s team began thinking about a new IBD affiliation last year, when private equity-backed Atria Wealth Solutions acquired Cadaret and some dozen BDs reached out to the practice, he says. Although they were happy with their longtime BD, Hoyt “thought it made sense to at least look around,” he says.

“If we were ever going to make a move, Commonwealth’s the one I've been hearing about for 25 years,” says Hoyt, praising the firm’s technology, compliance and equity research. An impressive tour of its San Diego and Boston-area corporate offices sealed the deal: “We didn't even go visit anyone else after that,” he says.

19 trends to watch in 2019

Macroeconomic trends and matters of convenience will move advisors, assets and markets next year in the ever-changing wealth management space.

1 Min Read

A spokeswoman for Cadaret, Grant declined to comment. The No. 32 IBD and other midsized IBDs CUSO Financial Services and Sorrento Pacific Financial operate as independent subsidiaries of Atria, which is also buying NEXT Financial Group.

Hoyt came to Cadaret in 1991 after tenures with Pruco Securities and two other firms, according to FINRA BrokerCheck. He affiliated with Commonwealth on Jan. 2. Roney, Klein and Loftus spent a combined 66 years with Cadaret, while Ahrens joined in 2005 after three years with Morgan Stanley.

The practice is managing its fee-based accounts — which make up about 35% of their client assets — through Commonwealth’s corporate RIA, according to Hoyt, who says that share has been growing in recent years. The practice is also changing its custodian from Pershing to Fidelity’s National Financial Services.

In the last two months of the year, Commonwealth added two teams from No. 1 IBD LPL Financial with more than $550 million in assets under management and 40 years at LPL between them. Daniels and other executives expressly say they seek out prospective advisors and home-office staffers who are nice.

With 13 partners who have average tenures of nearly 25 years in their roles, Commonwealth has a “boringly consistent” track record of the same ownership structure, Daniels says. The first quarter of 2019 also appears to be on the same pace as the previous year for recruiting, he says.

“What separates Commonwealth from the rest is that the quantity matters far less to me than the quality,” Daniels says. “We're off to a great start, but we remain extremely careful and selective in our recruiting, and careful and selective about who works in the home office, as well.”

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Recruiting Career moves Independent BDs M&A Commonwealth Financial Network
MORE FROM FINANCIAL PLANNING