Independent Cetera team fighting Avantax 'trade secret' lawsuit

A simmering legal feud between two of the largest tax-focused wealth management firms underscores the shifting challenges for independent financial advisors who switch brokerages  — and the industry's scrutiny of LinkedIn posts.

A previously-unreported lawsuit filed by the parent firm of Avantax Wealth Management cited a LinkedIn post by Brian Stern, the co-founder of Farpointe Wealth Partners, a branch that moved from Avantax to Cetera, as evidence of a "conspiracy" to recruit Avantax advisors to follow Stern to rival brokerage Cetera Financial Specialists. 

The complaint, filed in December 2021, alleges that Stern, three other Farpointe executives and Cetera wrongfully used "confidential/trade secret" information as part of the effort. Court papers in the case cite a photo on Stern's LinkedIn page depicting about 20 former Avantax advisors at Farpointe's conference in San Antonio a month earlier. Avantax alleges that the Farpointe founders' knowledge of its top producers is a trade secret.

Stern, Farpointe CEO Scott Rawlins, Chief Operating Officer Casey Griffin and Executive Vice President of Advisor Experience and Strategy Stephanie Schuller, as well as the Cetera Financial Group-owned brokerage and registered investment advisory firm used by Farpointe, have rejected the claims that they misappropriated trade secrets. Farpointe argued in its answer to the lawsuit that the 11 teams that moved to their branch at Cetera in Farpointe's first year and a half after launching in November 2020 are independent advisors with the right to do so. And they said Avantax has shared the supposedly "confidential" information online.   

"Far from confidential trade secret information, Avantax publicly promotes the status of its top producers to anyone who has LinkedIn or Google," Farpointe said in its answer to the lawsuit.

Dallas-based Blucora changed its name to that of its wealth management subsidiary Avantax after selling TaxAct, the other business that had been under its umbrella, late last year. The firm quietly filed the civil lawsuit in a Texas state court in Dallas, but the filing went unnoticed by the industry. Online legal portal UniCourt made court documents from the case available on its website. The case faces a potential trial date later this year, with the latest filing, in January, a stipulated confidentiality agreement and proposed protective order governing discovery. 

Representatives for Dallas-based Avantax and Los Angeles-based Cetera declined to discuss the case, citing policies against commenting on legal matters. Reached separately via email, Stern also declined to comment on behalf of himself, Rawlins, Griffin, Schuller and their Southlake, Texas-based firm.

The case underscores an emerging trend in which independent wealth managers engage in tactics like lawsuits or outright intimidation against advisors who are 1099 contractors and leave one brokerage firm for another. In high-stakes recruiting fights for advisory teams that can sometimes spill over into legal cases or arbitration, trade secret cases are typically associated with employee brokerage firms like Edward Jones or with wirehouses whose advisors are direct W-2 staff employees.

Even without "an express set of restrictions" such as a non-solicitation agreement, independent teams that switch brokerages may find themselves hit with a legal challenge by their prior firm, said Sharron Ash, the chief litigation counsel at the Hamburger Law Firm, which isn't involved in the case. Wealth management firms may file a lawsuit against a departed team like Farpointe in order to "scare off that firm from continuing to bring advisors over," she said.

"What they can accomplish and what they hope to accomplish can be different things," she added, referring to Avantax's goals with the lawsuit. "Litigation can sometimes be used as a warning that 'This is not a path that others should try to go down.'"

The legal fisticuffs signal a "newer phenomena in the independent channel" that extends to other firms besides Avantax, according to recruiter Jon Henschen of Henschen & Associates

In another recent case that went to arbitration, a branch with Advisor Group's Royal Alliance Associates prevailed over a Cambridge Investment Research broker who accused the rival network of advisory teams of violating recruiting rules.

Henschen called all of the lawsuits "just a heavy-handed measure to keep people from leaving."

"The firms, if they're having a lot of outflow, they pull these games on the advisors," he added. "The bigger you are, the more likely you are to get pushback from the broker-dealers nowadays. We're seeing more of it unfortunately."

Farpointe spans 13 offices with $1.3 billion in client assets. The firm received an investment of an undisclosed size from Cetera last year as part of a joint venture between the firms and another advisory practice for succession planning and outsourced wealth services for accounting firms. Stern had spent his entire 23-year career with Avantax and its predecessor firm, HD Vest, before leaving to start Farpointe in 2020. Rawlins' tenure with HD Vest included a stint as company president and head of several departments, and fellow executives Schuller and Griffin had each worked there for more than 20 years as well. Blucora acquired HD Vest in 2015, later rebranding it as Avantax. 

"Blucora is fully supportive of, and encourages, fair competition within the financial services industry," the firm's lawsuit stated. "However, it believes that companies must compete on a level-playing field — not by improperly leveraging competitors' confidential/trade secret information to recruit their high-performing [financial professionals]. Unfortunately, it appears that defendants Farpointe, Stern, Rawlins, Griffin and Schuller have made the use of Blucora's confidential/trade secret information the foundation of their business model and have further used violations of Griffin's and Schuller's non-solicit obligations (with funding from the Cetera defendants) in building their business."

In a March 2022 filing in the case, Farpointe said that Avantax lost a net 1,056 advisors, or nearly a quarter of its ranks of brokers, between 2016 and 2021, despite acquiring a onetime rival with 850 registered representatives in 2019. Frequent changes in management, a couple of shareholder proxy campaigns against the publicly traded firm and policies such as a fee charged to brokers whose clients held assets directly with mutual fund companies outside of Avantax took their toll, the filing said.

Farpointe alleged that Avantax took "inappropriate — and possibly illegal — steps to interfere with representatives who want to transfer their business away from Avantax" that included making false allegations about them before FINRA and other retaliatory actions. Avantax also sought to hold onto teams by offering them payments of hundreds of thousands of dollars, and in some cases millions of dollars, to stay, according to the filing.

"The representatives' independent contractor relationship with Avantax is 'at will' — it can be terminated by the representative or Avantax for any reason or no reason at all," Farpointe's filing stated. "Representatives are not subject to any contractual agreement or restriction that prevents them from moving their business to another firm at any time. This mobility is a core feature of the relationship between independent representatives and entities such as Avantax; representatives have the absolute right to vote with their feet regarding the performance of Avantax, particularly if Avantax makes decisions that negatively impact their business."

Cetera's lawyers filed an answer to Avantax's lawsuit last June.

"Blucora brought its claim for misappropriation of trade secrets (and conspiracy) in bad faith because there is no evidence that Blucora has trade secrets, that Cetera acquired any trade secret of Blucora 'by improper means,' or that Cetera disclosed or used, or threatened to disclose or use, any purported trade secret of Blucora," that document stated.

The plaintiffs argue that Farpointe's knowledge of Blucora's business, in the form of the practices that generate the most revenue each year, gave it an edge over its prior brokerage.

"There is no public list or compilation of [Avantax's] top-performing [financial professionals]," Blucora's lawsuit stated. "Blucora keeps this information confidential because knowledge of this information would provide competitors, such as Farpointe/Cetera with an unfair competitive advantage, because it would enable them to selectively target such recruits."

Farpointe countered that Avantax routinely posts congratulatory messages on social media recognizing the top producers, who often refer to their own status as well on their own sites and go on "a highly publicized annual trip" that includes many people outside the firm.

"Avantax regularly provides a list of top producers to unaffiliated product sponsor companies so that those companies can call on the top producers," according to Farpointe's filing. "Avantax recently began publicly marketing and branding the 'Avantax Elite' — representatives who qualify as top producers — in some cases with direct endorsement by Avantax President Todd Mackay."

The case could end in settlement directly by the parties or through mediation, get tossed by a judge or go all the way to trial, according to Ash of the Hamburger Law Firm. Because arbitrations are governed by the language of contracts, the case is unlikely to go into a FINRA-supervised proceeding if neither side has filed a motion to force the matter into the different forum by now, she said.

Henschen gave wealth management firms seeking to retain their brokers a piece of advice.

Tactics like lawsuits or veiled threats against advisors "drive reps to want to go fee-only and go away from broker-dealers who are hindering their freedoms," he said. "Keep your advisors happy. If you want to compete, do your job well."

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Regulation and compliance Lawsuits Recruiting Cetera Financial Group
MORE FROM FINANCIAL PLANNING